Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Steve Kenneally's avatar

Ooh, way to push my intellectual buttons! I love this topic so much I did my doctoral study on it.

I think one important thing to consider is that fantasy is never purely escapist. It's always rooted in the real, because people only understand the different and fantastical when there's an agreed 'normal' baseline it's differing from.

Possibly one of the big draws of fantasy in recent years - because I agree with you that in general fantasy is a literature of the past and science fiction a literature of the future - is that authors have been using fantasy to reimagine and reframe the past, not just escape to a romanticised version.

Now we're seeing queer fantasy stories, fantasy stories about people of colour, fantasy stories that interrogate and challenge a lot of accepted norms about the genre, about society, and how we think about our past/s.

It's transformative. And the power of reimagining the past is that it lets us reconstruct our present as well, in a much more intuitive way than a future-oriented science fiction can do. In my opinion, anyway.

Science fiction will tell you the best way to change the future is to change the present, which is true. Fantasy lets you reshape and reinterpret the past to actually change that present.

Thanks for such a thought-provoking article!

Expand full comment
Renee Hale's avatar

I enjoyed reading your thoughts on this, because I was mulling on the differences between the two genres myself. I like both genres, although if I had to choose, I would pick fantasy just for the magical elements. However, one thing I’ve been wondering about is why fantasy books and series seem to be much longer than sci fi ones. It’s pretty common for me to find a standalone, new release in sci fi somewhere between 300 and 400 pages long, but I’ve rarely found a fantasy new release of that size that’s not just the first in a trilogy or similar. Plus, if a book is going to be 600+ pages, it’s more often than not in the fantasy genre. This is all anecdotal, and it may be a recent trend, but I would be curious to know if you’ve noticed it or have any thoughts on why it might be happening.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts